A Parting Wish From Judge Collins

Judge Earl Collins


     Dear Fellow Judges,

          Your expression of appreciation at the Executive Board Meeting in Sarasota at the Hyatt was overwhelming.

     So many of you have influenced my life over the past years in so many positive ways.
I thank each of you for the award and the opportunity of serving as your Conference Manager for the past ten years.

     My parting wish is for the continuing success of the Florida Conference of County Court Judges.

Sincerely,

R. Earl Collins

CONGRATULATIONS

MONROE COUNTY

JUDGE WAYNE MILLER
New  Dean of the Florida
Judicial College

ALACHUA COUNTY

JUDGE PHYLLIS KOTEY
New Associate Dean of the Florida
Judicial College

Conference Committee Report
report.jpg (1662 bytes)
The Conference Committee met on October 25, 2000 at The Hyatt Hotel in Sarasota. Reports and discussion later approved by the Executive Board on Friday, October 27, 2000, are as follows:

The Conference came out about $14,500.00 in the black at our Winter Conference. However, payments for our lobbyists, awards, travel, etc., used most of that amount.

Cory Ciklin was unable to attend this workshop.

The following Conference and Workshop dates have been previously approved:

Winter Educational Conference 2001 – January 30 – February 3, 2001 – Radisson at the Port, Cape Canaveral

Spring Workshop 2001 – (Legislative Reception) - March 7-9, 2001 – Radisson at Tallahassee

Summer Educational Conference 2001 – July 11-14, 2001 – at The Registry, Naples

Sites for Fall 2001, Winter 2002 and Spring 2002 will be set by Judge Ciklin as soon as possible.

All contracts for the Conference scheduled have been delivered to Judge Ciklin.

Civil Rules Report
Ronald A. Legendre, Chair


The amendments to the Rules of Civil Procedure approved by the Florida Supreme Court take effect on Jan. 1, 2001.

Fla. R. Jud. Admin. 2.071 (d) contains new sub-sections regarding testimony taken through communication equipment. The oath must be administered by an authorized person who is present with the witness. This means the judge cannot do so.

Ron Legendre reported on the work of the Civil Rules Committee of The Florida Bar.

The committee discussed the methods used by judges around the state in handling deficiency judgments after a motor vehicle is repossessed.

The committee discussed motions for default judgments that had the expert attorney’s fee affidavits attached which were signed by an attorney associated with plaintiff’s attorney’s firm, and thus were not disinterested.

It was noted that judges should require original promissory notes to be filed before entering final judgments on the notes for two reasons: a) to make sure documentary stamps are attached, and b) to prevent plaintiff from assigning the original note to a BFP.

The committee also discussed plaintiffs who hold paper permitting a high legal rate of interest on a debt, but delay filing suit so that higher interest will accrue, rather than seeking an earlier judgment that pays 10% interest. Broward County v. Finlayson, 555 So. 2d. 1211 (Fla. 1990) allows a judge to consider the equities involved in this practice.

Note: Judges assigned to a civil division may wish to sit in on future committee meetings to hear some of the discussions.

Sentencing Report -
Aymer L. "Buck" Curtin, Chair

Eleven members of the Sentencing Committee met on October 26, 2000 in Sarasota.

Civil restitution liens imposed pursuant to F.S. 960.282 were discussed. The Committee felt individual judges and their clerks must tailor their own policy to implement this lien. No further action or discussion occurred.

Judges Mary Catherine Green and Michael Raiden of Polk County had requested that the Committee review the effects of a charge of driving while license suspended or revoked (DWLS) upon holders of Florida Driver Licenses. The Committee is interested in reviewing the entire statutory scheme to distinguish the suspension of driving privileges as a result of the inability to pay traffic infraction fines from those suspensions resulting from certain criminal convictions. The Committee felt this review may involve the Judiciary into substantive issues of law which would be more appropriate for Legislative review. Without specific legislative guidelines, the Committee suggested that judges rely upon judicial discretion in sentencing and communication with the State and defense counsel regarding filing policies and sentencing philosophy.

    

Criminal Rules Report
Olin W. Shinholser, Chair

The Criminal Rules Committee discussed a number of proposed rule changes being considered by the Florida Bar Criminal Rules Committee:

Rule to require judges to address joint representation of co-defendants by the same attorney to ensure that no conflict of interest exists;

Whether Rule 1.171 should be modified to address judicial role in plea negotiations;
Whether modifications should be made pertaining to rules regarding the setting of bail and pretrial release;

Post conviction DNA testing.

The committee took no specific action. However, the committee recommended that any rule addressing joint representation of counsel apply to both retained and court-appointed counsel.

Family & Juvenile Report
Deborah White-Labora, Chair

juv.jpg (1629 bytes)
The Juvenile and Family Law Committee of the Conference of County Court Judges met on October 26, 2000. The committee will focus on juvenile issues and a judicial volunteer mentoring and teaching program for adolescents in the custody of the Department of Juvenile Justice. This program will be patterned after the Sisters of the Heart program founded by Judge Rippingille in Miami Dade County. The program links delinquent adolescents with adult role modes and provides cultural experiences and opportunities to learn about the justice system and observe hearings and trials.
The Committee members will be meeting with officials from the Department of Juvenile Justice during our spring planning meeting in Tallahassee in March to obtain their assistance in planning our program. During the summer conference Judge Rippingille will be giving a training session on how to set up a program in your county.
The Committee welcomes your participation. Several of our judges have indicated an interest in the program and Judge Rippingille is preparing a brochure on the program to be available at the winter conference. You may contact Judge Rippingille at (305) 252-5858.